Premise Hypothesis Relation
1. Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. JC lives in Pittsburgh, PA. contradiction
2. Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. MB prefers cats to dogs. neutral
3. Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. JC was NOT the dog’s owner. entailment
4. Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. Owner is defined as any person having a right of property in an animal. JC was NOT the dog’s legal owner. entailment
5. Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. Owner is defined as any person having a right of property in an animal, OR who keeps or harbors an animal. JC was NOT the dog’s legal owner. contradiction
6. Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. Owner is defined as any person having a right of property in an animal, OR who keeps or harbors an animal, OR who has it in his care, OR acts as its custodian. JC was NOT the dog’s legal owner. contradiction
7. Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. Owner is defined as any person having a right of property in an animal, OR who keeps or harbors an animal, OR who has it in his care, OR acts as its custodian, OR who knowingly permits a dog to remain on any premises occupied by him or her. JC was NOT the dog’s legal owner. contradiction