| 1. |
Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. |
JC lives in Pittsburgh, PA. |
contradiction |
| 2. |
Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. |
MB prefers cats to dogs. |
neutral |
| 3. |
Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. |
JC was NOT the dog’s owner. |
entailment |
| 4. |
Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. Owner is defined as any person having a right of property in an animal. |
JC was NOT the dog’s legal owner. |
entailment |
| 5. |
Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. Owner is defined as any person having a right of property in an animal, OR who keeps or harbors an animal. |
JC was NOT the dog’s legal owner. |
contradiction |
| 6. |
Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. Owner is defined as any person having a right of property in an animal, OR who keeps or harbors an animal, OR who has it in his care, OR acts as its custodian. |
JC was NOT the dog’s legal owner. |
contradiction |
| 7. |
Client JC, an Evanston, IL resident, was caring for a friend’s dog when the dog bit MB. Owner is defined as any person having a right of property in an animal, OR who keeps or harbors an animal, OR who has it in his care, OR acts as its custodian, OR who knowingly permits a dog to remain on any premises occupied by him or her. |
JC was NOT the dog’s legal owner. |
contradiction |